ELMIRA, N.Y. (WENY) -- Arnot Ogden Medical Center is on the hook for a $5 million judgment after a Chemung County Supreme Court jury found a former surgeon liable for causing catastrophic injuries during a 2017 surgery. In a statement given to WENY News, Arnot remained adamant that it disagreed with the verdict and is currently exploring its legal options.  

“The hospital is... reviewing its legal rights in response to the jury’s verdict,” said Hospital Spokesman Ken Roberts. 

The patient, who was represented by Ziff Law Firm LLP of Elmira, underwent a laparoscopic cholecystectomy because of gallstones on August 15, 2017. During the surgery the patient, whose name was not released, received serious injury to their bile ducts requiring transport by ambulance to Strong Memorial Hospital for a repair procedure.  

“Unfortunately, my client will likely continue to suffer serious medical problems related to his injury for the rest of his life. However, observing justice be done in the courtroom under very intense conditions will allow him and his wife to begin finding peace with what has happened,” said Christina Sonsire, partner at the Ziff Law Firm. 

Since the surgery the patient has endured the need of additional surgery, multiple hospitalizations for sepsis, small bowel obstructions and other complications. 

“Arnot Ogden Medical Center is disappointed with the verdict and maintains that the care and treatment rendered by its former surgeon, Dr. Gary Mann, was appropriate and consistent with the standard of care despite the patient suffering an unfortunate complication,” said Roberts.  

Sonsire, who represented the patient and his wife, added that for the past five years the case was “intensely litigated.” That sentiment was shared by Roberts.  

“The lengthy litigation process reflects the opposing views of the parties throughout the case.  The hospital appreciates the efforts by the jury members in weighing the evidence and coming to its conclusion,” said Roberts.  

That lengthy litigation process apparently did not include settlement talks.  

“Throughout that time Arnot Ogden Medical Center never expressed any interest in resolving it. My clients are grateful that the jury worked so hard to understand the medicine and determine how the injury occurred,” said Sonsire.